Eusebius McKaiser: Why the bullshit curfew is critically harmful


Crises reveal the true nature of individuals and states. 

I used to be pondering of this final evening as I processed simply one of many many bulletins made by President Cyril Ramaphosa in his deal with to the nation wherein he introduced that we are going to, as of Sunday, be transferring to alert degree one of many nationwide lockdown that has been in place now for six months. 

Alongside the best way he introduced the choice that the curfew will stay in place. The one change is that the curfew will likely be lowered barely in period and can now apply between midnight and 4am.

The curfew has bothered me deeply for an extended whereas now however I had needed to replicate on what it’s that events my discomfort. I believe I’ve figured it out. The issues with the curfew are critical when you think about your self a democrat dedicated to sure norms.

Firstly, the curfew reveals to us a state that’s keen to behave irrationally. There isn’t a coherent logic for the continued imposition of a curfew. The curfew shouldn’t be in step with the goals of containing the unfold of Covid-19 and due to this fact has no place in a raft of measures that may solely be justified with regards to the Covid-19 pandemic. We aren’t extra prone to Covid-19 between midnight and 4am than the remainder of the day. To that extent, the curfew is bigoted and nonsensical.

 Secondly, and associated to this irrationality, is the refusal of the South African authorities to supply causes for selections which can be, on the face of it, irrational. One of many many normative options of the democracy we signed up for in 1994 is that ours was meant to be a democracy that isn’t solely sure by the calls for of rational behaviour on the a part of the state but in addition by the demand for causes to be said and defined publicly for selections taken by the state. 

By saying however not explaining a patently complicated curfew choice, President Ramaphosa reveals to us that he’s the pinnacle of a authorities that’s keen to behave irrationally and in an opaque method. There isn’t a respect for the norm of transparency.

In fact, he can’t select transparency simply when transparency will present up the irrationality of the curfew choice. 

However that’s exactly why, as residents, we’re those who ought to demand, always, that when the federal government acts, it does so with accompanying explanations for the choices it has taken. In any other case we’re again in pre-1994 territory, a time when the undemocratic state didn’t see itself as morally obligated to behave rationally, fairly, and transparently. We can’t let this authorities get away with habituating reasons-averse methods of doing issues.

These are usually not the one concerns why this foolish curfew is bothering me. 

It additionally bothers me as a result of it reveals the hazards of an anti-democratic creep underneath the pretext of retaining us all protected. This yr has allowed all societies to ask themselves a societal-level query: “What sort of society will we wish to be?” 

Our state is keen to enroll in some profoundly anti-democratic responses to this silent query imposed by the Covid-19 pandemic. We must be unsleeping to this anti-democratic flip, name it out and push again in opposition to it. 

The erosion of freedoms invariably occurs slowly and by no means in a single day. It’s due to this fact inadequate for us to moan quietly in regards to the curfew. We must be making loud noises to indicate off our discontent and power authorities to desert this silly choice it has not even felt the necessity to clarify to us.

Begin off by interested by this within the bluntest phrases. Ramaphosa asking you to be house by midnight is correct up there together with your mother and father telling you, “So long as you reside underneath our roof you’ll abide by our legal guidelines!” 

Besides the ANC authorities shouldn’t be our guardian and the ANC doesn’t personal the nation. 

That’s aside from the truth that we’re not youngsters both.  

And even when we have been, it’s extra probably that youngsters will behave if they aren’t condescended to however revered as able to understanding causes.

The willingness of our authorities to behave from inside a framework of misplaced paternalism should be critiqued and rejected by all of us, no matter our particular person ideological and different variations. Nobody must be comfortable to reside in a state wherein an irrational curfew is imposed.

We aren’t in a warfare. The language of warfare, within the struggle to include Covid-19, shouldn’t be abused by the state. Energetic analogies will be extremely efficient. They’re helpful communications units. They can be linguistic trickery to justify bullshit. 

The curfew is bullshit. Allow us to all oppose it as irrational, pointless, and revealing a state that’s keen to behave arbitrarily like a power-drunk Huge Brother.

The views expressed are these of the writer and don’t replicate the official coverage or place of the Mail & Guardian.