Jimmy Sensible tried to level finger of suspicion at lodge supervisor, witness says


Richard Patenaude, 56, informed courtroom Friday that he had a dialog with Sensible someday after Collison’s stays have been recovered from a culvert in North Dundas Township in April 2014.

“He (Sensible) appeared to assume that Mr. Ivan Merkley had one thing to do with Mr. Collison’s demise,” Patnenaude informed Sensible’s first-degree homicide trial.

Courtroom has heard that Merkley was the supervisor of Chesterville’s McCloskey Resort the place Collison generally stayed. Merkley has testified that he gave Collison room and board in return for doing odd jobs across the lodge.

Patenaude stated Sensible prompt that Merkley was indignant at Collison for failing to pay his hire. “Nicely, apparently, he (Sensible) thought Mr. Merkley had a .22 and that Mr. Merkley shot Mr. Collison,” Patenaude testified.

Cross-examined by defence lawyer Ian Carter, Patenaude conceded that he beforehand informed police a barely totally different story. In his police assertion, Patenaude stated he heard from Sensible that Merkley had threatened Collison with a gun.  

“He (Sensible) was form of pointing the finger at Mr. Merkley,” Patenaude informed the jury.

Throughout his testimony earlier this week, Merkley stated he didn’t shoot Collison and couldn’t perceive why anybody would assume as a lot. “I’m not that sort of man, eh?” stated Merkley, 88. “Working a lodge, you be taught to get together with folks.”

Crown lawyer Jason Pilon has informed jurors that Sensible tried to deflect consideration from himself within the aftermath of Collison’s homicide.

Earlier, the transcript of a taped OPP interview with Chesterville home-owner Betty Stewart was additionally entered into proof. The interview was performed in October 2009, two moths after Collison’s disappearance. Stewart died in Could 2010.

On the time of the interview, Stewart owned a house on County Highway three that Collison typically visited. Courtroom has heard that Sensible rented a trailer and storage on the identical property.  

Within the interview, Stewart known as Collison “a tough man to foretell.” “He got here right here when he didn’t have something to eat and he was hungry, or wanted a bathe, or he wanted a recent change of garments,” Stewart stated.

Stewart stated Collison was “an actual good carpenter” who would go on a two-day bender on the finish of each month when his incapacity cheque arrived. He’d spend all of it, she stated, “on booze and girls.”

A father and handyman who suffered psychological well being and dependancy points, Collison, 58, disappeared in late August 2009. His skeletal stays have been discovered 5 years later.

Sensible, 77, a former mechanic, is now on trial for first-degree homicide. Pilon has informed the jury that Sensible thought-about Collison a pest and a nuisance, and shot him “execution-style.”

Courtroom has heard that Collison was shot at the very least 3 times from behind and died from a gunshot to the again of the cranium. Forensic scientists discovered the bullet lodged within the entrance of his cranium, above his eyebrow.

The jury trial is the primary within the province to be held throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. Plexiglass has been put in all through the courtroom. Jurors sit two-metres aside in a big jury field separated by plexiglass panels.

Crown and defence attorneys are additionally separated by plexiglass. The choose, jurors and attorneys all enter the courtroom with masks, and take away them solely once they’re seated or talking.

Many witnesses have testified by video, which has prompted a number of technical hiccups. Among the many challenges has been to make sure that witnesses are capable of see displays or police statements referred to by attorneys in the middle of questioning.