our check is to make the HSC truthful and faculties secure for all, lecturers included

The federal government’s plan for public faculties has all college students attending in the future per week from Could 11, progressively growing till time period three, when everybody can be again full-time.


What does this imply for Yr 12 college students in public faculties? Properly, Yr 12 begin on Could 11 with in the future per week face-to-face instructing for 4 weeks, growing to 2 days for the remaining 4 weeks of time period, a complete of 12 attainable face-to-face college days. That compares with about 40 days for personal and Catholic college college students.

In fact, there may be nonetheless provision for on-line studying within the 28 days when the scholars aren’t in school subsequent time period, however at this stage of the HSC, face-to-face instructing and entry to highschool amenities, equivalent to workshops and science labs, are vital. As an illustration, any excellent necessary science practicals must be squeezed into these 12 days, in addition to common classes.

The HSC curriculum is tight and college students might want to cowl numerous floor that would not be coated on-line, significantly in sensible topics.

Why can’t this be finished in time period three? The reply: time period three is when trial HSC and HSC sensible exams happen and main works and faculty assessments are submitted to the NSW Schooling Requirements Authority. It’s the ultimate time period of the HSC 12 months. NESA has confirmed that the HSC exams will go forward as standard in time period four and has prolonged the deadline for submission of main works by a fortnight, however realistically, there may be not numerous time to spare.


College students with solely 12 days at college in time period 2 won’t have the identical preparation as personal college college students with 40 days at college. These 12 months 12 college students complaining that that is unfair are proper – it’s unfair and it’s much more unfair for deprived college students, for whom the every day interactions and assist of lecturers make all of the distinction in serving to them over the road.

The NSW Academics’ Federation additionally has criticised the federal government’s plan as unfair and desires it to prioritise 12 months 12 within the return to highschool, as Catholic faculties are doing. The Premier’s sharp response to the federation – that lecturers simply wished to proceed on-line supply indefinitely – is unhelpful, and has incensed lecturers. They’ve risen to the difficulties brought on by the pandemic by delivering on-line studying inside a remarkably brief timeframe, whereas persevering with face-to-face instructing for youngsters remaining at college.

Underneath the federal government’s staged return to highschool, lecturers must divide bigger lessons into smaller teams for social distancing and must repeat classes. Whereas instructing college students face-to-face on in the future per week, they may nonetheless have to sustain with on-line lesson preparation and marking and evaluation for everybody till time period three.


This represents a dramatic improve in trainer workload and is an pointless duplication of effort at a time when many lecturers worry their well being can be in danger when college goes again. Whereas the proof suggests college students is probably not important spreaders of the virus, adults are – and lecturers should work alongside fellow lecturers and different grownup workers. The federal government wants to make sure that faculties are secure for the adults in addition to the youngsters.

And it wants to present precedence to Yr 12 college students’ instant return to highschool full-time to make sure they’ve a sporting likelihood of finishing the HSC on a par with their personal college friends.

Dorothy Hoddinott is a former state highschool principal and is presiding pro-chancellor on the College of Sydney.

Most Seen in Nationwide